Shopify vs BigCommerce: Which Should You Choose?
Shopify and BigCommerce are both fully hosted commerce platforms that handle hosting, security, and updates for a monthly fee. Shopify is known for its polished ease of use, huge app store, and design ecosystem, while BigCommerce packs more advanced features into its base plans and charges no extra transaction fees on any payment gateway. Shopify tends to win on simplicity and ecosystem breadth; BigCommerce often wins on built-in features and no forced payment fees. For most small stores Shopify is smoother; feature-heavy or multichannel sellers may prefer BigCommerce.
- Both are
- Fully hosted SaaS commerce platforms with hosting, security, and updates included
- Transaction fees
- Shopify adds extra fees unless you use Shopify Payments; BigCommerce charges none on any gateway (BigCommerce.com)
- App ecosystem
- Shopify has a much larger third-party app store; BigCommerce builds more features in natively
- Sales limits
- BigCommerce plans have annual sales thresholds that force upgrades; Shopify tiers are feature-based (BigCommerce.com)
- Pricing
- Both offer tiered monthly plans in similar ranges plus payment processing (U.S., 2026)
- Best for
- Shopify for design and ease; BigCommerce for built-in features and no gateway fees
How the two platforms compare at a glance #
Shopify and BigCommerce are close cousins: both are hosted, all-in-one commerce platforms that take servers, security, and updates off your plate for a monthly fee. The differences are in philosophy. Shopify prioritizes a beautifully simple experience, an enormous app marketplace, and a deep design ecosystem, betting that most stores would rather add features through apps than have everything built in. BigCommerce packs more advanced commerce features directly into its base plans, aiming to reduce the number of paid add-ons you need, and it notably charges no extra transaction fees regardless of which payment gateway you use. Both scale well and suit serious sellers. Choosing between them comes down to whether you value ecosystem breadth and polish or richer native features and payment flexibility. Because both are hosted, our /services/ecommerce-development team can build cleanly on either, so the decision should follow your feature needs and budget rather than any technical limitation on our side.
Pricing and transaction fees #
Both platforms use tiered monthly plans that land in broadly similar U.S. ranges, but the fee structures differ in ways that matter. Shopify adds an extra transaction fee on every sale unless you use its own Shopify Payments, effectively nudging you toward its processor. BigCommerce charges no additional transaction fees on any payment gateway, so you can pick the processor with the best rates without a penalty, which can save money for stores with specific banking or regional needs. BigCommerce plans, however, include annual online-sales thresholds that automatically bump you to a higher tier once you cross them, so a fast-growing store may face upgrades tied to revenue rather than features. Shopify's tiers are gated by features and rates instead. Neither model is universally cheaper; it depends on your sales volume and preferred processor. To compare realistic total costs for your projected revenue, our /tools/cost-calculator and /pricing pages help you weigh monthly fees, processing, and add-ons side by side rather than guessing.
Ease of use and setup #
Shopify has a reputation as the friendliest commerce platform, and it is well earned. Its admin is clean, onboarding is guided, and launching a good-looking store is achievable quickly even without technical skills. BigCommerce is also user-friendly but presents more settings and native features up front, which gives you power at the cost of a slightly steeper initial learning curve. Beginners often find Shopify more immediately intuitive, while users who want fine-grained control appreciate BigCommerce exposing more options without needing apps. Both offer solid documentation and support. In practice, either can be set up successfully by a motivated owner, though Shopify's smoother onboarding shortens time to launch. When clients want a store configured, themed, and optimized correctly from the start on either platform, they lean on our /services/ecommerce-development team to handle setup so they can focus on products and marketing. If minimizing technical friction is your top priority, Shopify edges ahead; if you want more built-in control immediately, BigCommerce holds its own.
Built-in features versus apps #
This is the core philosophical split. BigCommerce builds more advanced commerce features into its plans natively, such as robust product options, multi-currency handling, and B2B-friendly tools, aiming to reduce reliance on paid extensions. Shopify keeps its core lean and expects you to add capabilities through its vast app store, which offers thousands of integrations for nearly any need. The trade-off is real: BigCommerce may cover more out of the box, potentially lowering add-on costs, while Shopify's ecosystem is broader and more polished, but stacking many paid apps can raise your monthly spend. Heavy app use can also affect performance and complexity. For stores needing lots of specialized functionality, tallying the true cost of required apps on each platform is essential before deciding. When custom features or connections to other systems are involved, our /services/api-crm-integrations work spans both platforms. The right choice depends on how many of your needs each covers natively versus how much you would spend bolting them on.
Design, themes, and customization #
Shopify leads on design ecosystem depth. It offers a large selection of professional themes, a mature theme marketplace, and the Liquid templating language that designers and developers know well, making custom storefronts straightforward. BigCommerce provides quality themes too and uses its Stencil framework for customization, but its theme selection and third-party design community are smaller than Shopify's. Both let you tailor look and feel extensively, and both support headless setups for teams wanting a fully custom front end. For a brand that cares deeply about a distinctive, polished storefront and wants a wide pool of designers familiar with the platform, Shopify's ecosystem is an advantage, and it underpins our /services/shopify-web-design work. BigCommerce is perfectly capable of a great-looking store, just with a somewhat narrower design community to draw from. If bespoke design and easy access to theme talent matter most, Shopify has the edge; if you are comfortable within a smaller but solid design ecosystem, BigCommerce will not hold your store's appearance back.
Multichannel and B2B selling #
Both platforms sell beyond your own website, but they emphasize different strengths. Shopify has mature integrations for social selling, marketplaces, and point-of-sale, plus a huge app ecosystem to extend channels, making it strong for consumer brands going omnichannel. BigCommerce offers robust native multichannel tools and has historically leaned into B2B and wholesale features, with capabilities like customer groups, price lists, and quote workflows available more readily, which appeals to businesses selling to other businesses. If your model blends retail and wholesale, BigCommerce's native B2B tooling can reduce the add-ons you would otherwise need on Shopify. Connecting either platform to a CRM, ERP, or wholesale portal is common, and it aligns with our /services/api-crm-integrations and /services/client-portals work. Evaluate which platform natively supports your specific selling channels and buyer types, because the gap is less about capability and more about how much you must add on. For pure B2C simplicity Shopify shines; for mixed B2B and B2C, BigCommerce often fits more cleanly.
Performance, scalability, and reliability #
Because both are hosted SaaS platforms, they handle infrastructure, security, and traffic spikes for you, delivering strong baseline performance and reliability without you managing servers. Shopify's global infrastructure is battle-tested at massive scale, famously handling enormous sales events, and BigCommerce likewise offers dependable uptime and the ability to grow with your business. Neither leaves you patching servers or worrying about hosting quality the way self-hosted platforms do. Where you can still influence speed is in how the storefront is built: heavy themes, oversized images, and too many apps can slow either platform, which is why our /services/speed-optimization work applies even to hosted stores. In short, both platforms remove the biggest reliability headaches and scale comfortably for the vast majority of businesses, so performance is rarely the deciding factor between them. Your storefront build quality and app discipline will affect real-world speed more than the underlying platform choice, so focus optimization effort there rather than assuming one platform is inherently faster.
Support, documentation, and community #
Both platforms back you with vendor support since both are hosted SaaS products, but the surrounding ecosystems differ in size. Shopify offers extensive official support, thorough documentation, and one of the largest communities in commerce, including a huge network of agencies, developers, and designers familiar with the platform, so finding help or hiring talent is easy. BigCommerce also provides solid official support and documentation, and its community is capable, but it is smaller, meaning a narrower pool of specialists and third-party resources to draw on. For most store owners either level of support is more than adequate, since the vendor handles infrastructure regardless. The practical difference shows up when you need niche expertise or want many candidates to build and maintain your store: Shopify's larger ecosystem gives more options. When you want a partner who knows either platform deeply, our /services/ecommerce-development team fills that role. Factor in how much you value a large talent pool and abundant tutorials versus a smaller but perfectly competent support community when deciding.
When to choose each, and a verdict #
Choose Shopify if you value the smoothest ease of use, the widest app and design ecosystem, and a polished, well-supported experience, and if you are comfortable using Shopify Payments to avoid extra transaction fees; it is the safe, popular pick for most consumer brands. Choose BigCommerce if you want more advanced features built into your base plan, freedom to use any payment gateway without added fees, and native tools for B2B or multichannel selling; it can lower add-on costs for feature-heavy stores. For the typical U.S. small business prioritizing simplicity and ecosystem, Shopify is usually the pragmatic winner. For sellers with rich feature needs, wholesale channels, or specific payment-processing requirements, BigCommerce is a compelling alternative worth serious consideration. Both are excellent, low-maintenance hosted platforms, so the decision hinges on your feature and payment priorities. A quick /free-website-audit or a chat via /contact can map your requirements to the platform that fits best, saving you from paying for capabilities you will never use or missing ones you need.
FAQ
Does BigCommerce charge transaction fees?
No, BigCommerce charges no additional transaction fees on any payment gateway, so you can choose the processor with the best rates. Shopify, by contrast, adds an extra fee unless you use Shopify Payments, which effectively encourages you to use its own processor.
Which has more apps, Shopify or BigCommerce?
Shopify has a much larger third-party app store with thousands of integrations. BigCommerce has fewer apps but builds more features natively into its plans, so you may need fewer add-ons. Which matters more depends on whether your needs are covered out of the box.
Is BigCommerce or Shopify better for B2B?
BigCommerce has historically offered stronger native B2B and wholesale tools, such as customer groups, price lists, and quote workflows. Shopify can do B2B, especially on higher plans and with apps. For mixed B2B and B2C selling, BigCommerce often requires fewer add-ons.
Do BigCommerce plans force upgrades based on sales?
Yes, BigCommerce plans include annual online-sales thresholds that automatically move you to a higher tier once you exceed them. Shopify's tiers are gated by features and rates rather than revenue, so a fast-growing store may hit BigCommerce upgrades tied to sales volume.
Which is easier to use for beginners?
Shopify is generally considered the easier platform for beginners thanks to its clean admin and guided onboarding. BigCommerce is also user-friendly but exposes more settings and native features up front, giving more control at the cost of a slightly steeper initial learning curve.
Can I customize the design on both?
Yes. Shopify offers a large theme marketplace and the Liquid templating language with a big design community. BigCommerce provides quality themes and its Stencil framework. Both support deep customization and headless builds, though Shopify has a broader pool of designers familiar with its ecosystem.
How Local Web Advisor checks this for you
Is your own website getting e-commerce right?
Our free AI audit scans your site and tells you — in plain English — exactly what to fix for e-commerce and seven other areas, with the business impact and the fix for each. No login needed to start.
Run my free website audit →Was this helpful?